New at Safeway – Chocolate Chewy Cookies and Peppermint Chewy Ice Cream Sandwich Recipe


New Signature SELECT Chocolate Chewy Cookies

Just in time for the holiday season, Safeway has a new and exclusive addition in the bakery with its new Chocolate Chewie Cookie.  The Chocolate Chewies are rich, fudgy, indulgent cookies that melt in your mouth!  They are cross between a fudge brownie and a chocolate cookie, thus the name chewies.

The cookies are made with egg whites, so you get that light and fluffy texture with a crispy exterior and chewy interior.   The cookies have pecans for an extra crunch.  The best part is that each chewie contains under 100 calories and less than 5 grams of fat.

Not only is it perfect for dunking in milk, but it’s also the ultimate cookie for entertaining.  You don’t need to tell your guests that you didn’t bake these because they will never know!  They look and taste homemade and frankly are close enough because they are baked fresh daily in your local Safeway bakery.



Peppermint Chewy Ice Cream Sandwich

I created a simple, yet indulgent ice cream sandwich dessert that is perfect for the holidays.  Whether you are hosting friends or family or having an intimate dinner with your immediate family, this Peppermint Chocolate Chewy Ice Cream Sandwich will be a hit for your event!

The ice cream sandwiches feature the Chocolate Chewies as the cookie and the Signature SELECT Peppermint Ice Cream for the sandwich interior.

The peppermint ice cream has swirls of peppermint marbled throughout the mint ice cream and green peppermint candy for extra crunchy texture.  It’s perfect for the holiday season on its own, but paired with the chocolate chewies, the combination of chocolate and mint is heavenly!



How to Make Ice Cream Sandwiches

Simply pick up the Chocolate Chewies from your local Safeway bakery and the peppermint ice cream from the freezer aisle.  If you want the extra flair from the sprinkles – I recommend red and white sanding sugar or the red candy sprinkles.

Let the ice cream soften for about 5 minutes. Use a large ice cream scooper to scoop about 1/2 cup of ice cream per sandwich.  Place the ice cream on the bottom cookie and top with a 2nd cookie.  Gently squeeze the 2 cookies together until you have a sandwich.  I took a knife and went around the sandwich to smoothe the ice cream so that it was uniform.

If you want extra flair for your cookie, roll the ice cream sandwich in sprinkles on a plate, gently pressing so they stick to the ice cream.  Plate the ice cream sandwiches and then place them in the freezer until the ice cream freezes again.


Sale on Chocolate Chewies and Ice Cream

The new Chocolate Chewies are on sale for $3.50 for 12 through December 1st and the Signature SELECT Peppermint Ice Cream is on sale for $2.49 when you buy 5 or more participating items through November 12th.  The Betty Crocker Sprinkles and the Wilton Sprinkles are on sale for 25% off through Dec. 1st.

If you make these ice cream sandwiches, be sure to tag Super Safeway on Instagram so we can give your post some love!  Let us know your thoughts on the new cookies below.

If you love these cookies, be sure to also check out the delicious new Berry Chantilly Cake available in the bakery at Safeway.


This is a sponsored post on behalf of Safeway to introduce the new Chocolate Chewy Cookies. As always, opinions are my own and I appreciate and encourage your support of the brands that make this site possible.


SuperSafeway is a blog devoted to helping you find the best deals at Safeway in the Denver division.  Every week we find and share the best advertised and unadvertised deals at Safeway with and without coupons.  We also share recipes and weekly meal planning ideas based on sales to maximize your savings.  For more low prices, check out Super Safeway’s weekly ad coupon matchup page.  Stay updated on the best deals by following Super Safeway on Facebook, on Twitter, on Instagram, or Pinterest and subscribe to our newsletter.

* Please note – Savings information is based on Colorado pricing and the Safeway Coupon Policy for the Denver Division which includes Colorado, Nebraska, New Mexico, Wyoming, and South Dakota. Your market may vary. *





About The Author

2 thoughts on “New at Safeway – Chocolate Chewy Cookies and Peppermint Chewy Ice Cream Sandwich Recipe”

  1. I went to buy some lunchables for my son yesterday and one of the Assistant Store Managers greeted everyone with a tray of these freshly baked cookies offering a sample taste. They were absolutely delicious! I will definitely be buying them for my next special occasion.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top