Safeway Bakery Cakes, Pastries, Artisan Breads and More

Safeway Bakery

If you need fresh baked goods for an upcoming event or social gathering, be sure to head into your local Safeway bakery where you will find an amazing assortment of cakes, cookies, pies, artisan breads and more!  The Safeway bakery will easily become your favorite stop in the store!

Safeway offers a comprehensive selection of baked goods, cakes, pies, artisan bread, pastries, muffins, donuts, and more through its in-store bakeries.  While some of the items are brought in, Safeway bakes most of their bakery items fresh in-store daily. 

Safeway Cakes

Safeway offers a full selection of cakes in the bakery which are decorated by talented 5-star cake decorators that are truly cake artists.  The Safeway cake artists use freehand decorating skills as well as decoration kits and tools to prepare a variety of high-quality baked items.

The gorgeous bakery cakes truly set Safeway apart from other grocers in terms of design options that are available for pickup any day of the week. 

You can customize any cake in a single-layer round cake, stacked round or rectangular sheet cake in a variety of sizes.  Bring in a photo from Pinterest or online of your vision for a cake and the Safeway cake artists can work with you to bring your vision to life.   

After deciding on a party theme, if you want a unicorn cake, a licensed cake (i.e. Disney, dinosaurs, Trolls, etc.), or a hedgehog cake, Safeway can make it happen. 

You can order many bakery items online for pick up in-store from Safeway’s Order Ahead site

Photo sheet cakes are available at most Safeway bakery locations.   If you want a special customized cake with a photo of a birthday celebrant, a graduate, or for any celebration, simply bring the photo into your local bakery and the cake artist will work with you to customize your cake.




Safeway Custom Cake Flavors

Safeway’s bakery cakes are available to be customized in five delicious cake flavors plus 13 filling options.  You can also select from two icing/frosting flavors to top your cake. Choose either vanilla whipped icing or buttercream frosting. 

  • Carrot Cake
  • Chocolate Cake
  • Marble Cake
  • White Cake
  • Red Velvet

Cake Filling Options

  • White Buttercream
  • Caramel Whipped Icing

Safeway cake pricing varies based on the size, design, and intricacy of the custom cake.  Cakes start at $9.99.  You can also get a free custom smash cake for your baby’s first birthday at Safeway. 

The Safeway cake order form and cake catalog are not available online, however, you can call your local Safeway bakery to place an order over the phone.  If you are requesting a custom cake, it’s best to stop into your local store and bring a photo to the cake artist so you can fill out an order form in person. 

The cake artist will draw a rendering of your vision on the order form, or use your photo as the inspiration for the cake design. 

Be prepared to select the cake size, flavor, filling, and icing options while placing your order.


Safeway Bakery Entertaining Options

Safeway offers a huge selection of pies, pastries, read-made cakes, ice cream cakes, cupcakes, and cream-based cakes like Boston Creams and a nice selection of cheesecakes in the bakery.

One entertaining item that is unique to Safeway and a popular seller is the fresh-baked Artisan Fresh Fruit Tart. Perfect for entertaining guests year-round the 9-inch fruit tart has layers of fresh strawberries, blueberries, raspberries, and kiwi fruit over a delicious cream filling on a sugared puff pastry crust.

Safeway also carries individual fruit tarts if you are buying just for one.  You’ll find these in the refrigerated cases in the bakery department. 



Safeway Bakery Baked Goods

Also unique to and perfect for entertaining for a brunch, or any celebration is Safeway’s large selection of artisan bread, cream-based cakes, cheesecakes, pies, and pudding rings, and pastries. 

Artisan Bread – Choose from traditional French bread loaves, sourdough bread, baguettes, or the Signature SELECT Italian Breads (Como Italian, Kalamata Olive, Asiago Cheese, Artisan Pugliese, Artisan Renaissance Grain, or Rosemary Olive Oil Bread).  Safeway also has a nice selection of take and bake bread that you can bake at home. 

Bagels – Choose from Asiago Cheese, Everything Bagels, Blueberry, Plain, Toasted Sesame, Onion Bagels, Cheddar Cheese, Energy Bar, Poppy Seed, 7-Seed, Pretzel Bagels, and Multigrain.  The bagels are baked fresh in-store daily and are sold individually as well as in a 6-pack.

Cinnamon Rolls and Cinnamon Twirls – choose from traditional cinnamon rolls, or cream cheese iced cinnamon rolls in single-serve, 4-ct, 8 ct, or 10 count packages. 

Coffee Cakes and Fruit Bread – Choose from raspberry, cream cheese, or bear claw coffee cakes with a glaze, or an assortment of bread loaves like lemon bread, pumpkin bread, blueberry bread and more. 


Cookies – Safeway has a huge selection of cookies that are baked fresh in-store daily.  Choose from chocolate chip, chocolate chunk, sugar cookies, oatmeal raisin, cranberry oatmeal, peanut butter, and more. 

Croissants – Safeway has fresh-baked croissants that are available in 4 ct, 8 ct. or 12 ct.  Perfect for making sandwiches, 

Cupcakes – chocolate or vanilla flavored cupcakes are available with a variety of decorations and frosting options.

Donuts – choose from traditional glazed donuts, cake donuts, or apple fritters.  The donuts are baked fresh daily in the Safeway bakery. 

Muffins – choose from blueberry, chocolate chip, double chocolate, bran, banana nut, peach, pistachio, almond, and pumpkin muffins. 

Pudding rings are available in raspberry, lemon, blueberry, cream cheese, apple, pumpkin, cherry, and chocolate chip.  

Pies – available in both 8-inch and 11-inch options – choose from pumpkin, pecan, apple, cherry, apple crumb, cherry crumb, caramel apple crumb, banana cream pie, key lime pie, coconut cream pie, and blueberry.  Additional seasonal flavors may also be available. 

Rolls – Freshly baked rolls are available in a variety of options including sandwich rolls, kaiser rolls, pretzel buns, hoagie rolls, sourdough rolls, bolillo rolls, potato rolls, and whole wheat rolls.

Turnovers – fresh-baked cherry or apple turnovers are perfect for a weekend brunch.



If you want just a slice of cake or pie, rather than the whole cake,  Safeway’s got your back – choose from a wide selection of individually packaged cake slices, pie slices, or single-serve fruit tarts available in the bakery daily.

Safeway Gluten-Free Baked Goods

If you can’t tolerate gluten- Safeway has a nice selection of gluten-free layer cakes, including a chocolate cake and a raspberry shortbread layer cake. 

Additionally, Safeway also offers gluten-free baked goods like muffins, bread, and cookies that are brought in from gluten-free bakeries.

Safeway Holiday Baked Goods

In addition to seasonally decorated ready to buy cakes, Safeway offers gorgeous yule log cakes in the bakery for the holidays. Choose from 3 preset designs or request a custom design in-store. 


Safeway Bakery Hours

The Safeway bakery is open the same hours as Safeway stores which is 5 am to 11 pm, however, the bakery department is staffed from 5 am to 8 pm.


Be sure to check out additional posts related to the Safeway Bakery here: 

Free Birthday Cake for 1st Birthday

New at Safeway Chocolate Chewy Cookies

DIY Halloween Cookie and Cupcake Decorating Kits

Holiday Yule Log Cakes From Safeway Bakery

$5 Donut Friday

Check out a few of the AMAZING decorated cakes I recently photographed from the Safeway bakery at the Broadway and Mineral store in Littleton, Colorado.  Hopefully, this will provide inspiration for your next celebration where you may need a cake.






SuperSafeway is a blog devoted to helping you find the best deals at Safeway in the Denver division.  Every week we slice and dice the ad and tell you the best deals at Safeway with and without coupons.  For more low prices, check out Super Safeway’s weekly ad coupon matchup page. Want to stay updated on the best deals? If so, make sure to like Super Safeway on Facebook, join our Facebook group, follow us on TwitterInstagram, or Pinterest and subscribe to our newsletter.

* Please note – Savings information is based on Colorado pricing and the Safeway Coupon Policy for the Denver Division which includes Colorado, Nebraska, New Mexico, Wyoming and South Dakota. Your market may vary. Prices may vary per location*

About The Author

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top